Well Gurm, answering to your question is impossible, no one knows how he might react to this question.
Let me give you another.
What would you do if your state puts somebody you love (same people than you mentioned) and put it to death in the same cold way?
What would you do if you knew he/she was innocent but you couldn't prove it?
Would you still agree with such actions?
And in fact I gonna voice my opinion and NOT step aside, because where I live I'm in the majority. ;-)
Oh yes, I was going to forgot. Would you still be able to live with your statistical calculs if the 1 in X was just your wife/daughter/son?
And now Holly, you say we have to try something new! Well, fine with me. But death penalty IS NOT something new, it's even the oldest system on earth! The new system is not working well that's a fact! But it's new, needs new drivers and some tweaking.
I don't see how the society could justify to kill some people when the society itself is blamable for it.
And we have two examples: On my right US (well some parts of it), on my left Europe.
US does have death penalty and Europe doesn't (well some have but they are not used: anybody tell me if I'm wrong). Look at the criminal statistics. Europe wins easily.
I know that's not a good comparison, so many things differ! What would be interesting would be the comparison between two comparable american states, one with and one without death penalties, could anybody provide that?
Last rant for me this morning, going to cool off in math class.
Vlip
P.S: I'm not sure what you mean by "bleeding heart liberal" but my friends consider sometimes like the opposite of what you think you mean by that. So strange cultural difference, don't you think?
(inbetween if you could explain a little bit more what you mean with that, I'd be interested)
Let me give you another.
What would you do if your state puts somebody you love (same people than you mentioned) and put it to death in the same cold way?
What would you do if you knew he/she was innocent but you couldn't prove it?
Would you still agree with such actions?
And in fact I gonna voice my opinion and NOT step aside, because where I live I'm in the majority. ;-)
Oh yes, I was going to forgot. Would you still be able to live with your statistical calculs if the 1 in X was just your wife/daughter/son?
And now Holly, you say we have to try something new! Well, fine with me. But death penalty IS NOT something new, it's even the oldest system on earth! The new system is not working well that's a fact! But it's new, needs new drivers and some tweaking.
I don't see how the society could justify to kill some people when the society itself is blamable for it.
And we have two examples: On my right US (well some parts of it), on my left Europe.
US does have death penalty and Europe doesn't (well some have but they are not used: anybody tell me if I'm wrong). Look at the criminal statistics. Europe wins easily.
I know that's not a good comparison, so many things differ! What would be interesting would be the comparison between two comparable american states, one with and one without death penalties, could anybody provide that?
Last rant for me this morning, going to cool off in math class.
Vlip
P.S: I'm not sure what you mean by "bleeding heart liberal" but my friends consider sometimes like the opposite of what you think you mean by that. So strange cultural difference, don't you think?
(inbetween if you could explain a little bit more what you mean with that, I'd be interested)
Comment