What if... / Moral dilemmas

[Marshmallowman]

These are thought experiments, not analogies they are not realistic...otherwise what would be the point.

I found it interesting that 2 and 3 are very similar but, the fact I would answer them differently has me somewhat perplexed.

Using these as analogies to abortion is pretty weak though

[Umfriend]

Sorry if this offends anyone but for crying out loud, come up with some realistic analogies.

Why? What would it matter for your decisions? Can you provide me with two realistic analogies that would help us in understanding or finding anomalies in our moralities as clear as these do?