Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Matrox Do Something! (Flickering Part II)

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Matrox Do Something! (Flickering Part II)

    I have just changed my flickering G400 16MB part for a new, albeit identical, card. I have
    the same flickering problem, though this time it does not seem to be as bad as before. But
    I wonder if it gets worse with time...

    There is something clearly wrong with a significant number of the G400 16MB parts. I think
    Matrox should at least acknowledge the problem, explain its causes, and do something about
    it. The whole issue is even more interesting as the problem does not seem to be
    heat-related since all the cards I have tried, 3 in total, function correctly (in 3D, for
    example) at speeds that exceed the manufacturer's specifications.

    ------------------
    Celeron 500, Soyo 6BA+ IV, 128MB PC100, G400 16MB, SB Live!, Quantum FB CX 10GB UDMA 66

    Asus A7V, Duron 600@900, 192MB PC133@100, G200, Guillemot MUSE, etc.

  • #2
    No overclocking, strange AGP bus speeds, or anything? Also, the cards require a fair amount of power and your motherboard or PS might not be up to the task (pure conjecture). Have you tried the cards on other machines? If not definitely do that and see if you stil have the same problems. What kind of flickering are you talking about? Have you changed refresh rates? Just trying to figure out what kinda problem you'r having...

    Jon
    My baby...

    QDI Brilliant IV - Bios 2.0 Beta (Win2000 updates - email me if you want it!)
    2 Pentium III 500 MHz
    256 MB PC-100 SDRAM
    Matrox Millenium G200 8 MB SGRAM - Bios 2.6-20
    2 Creative Labs 3D Blaster Voodoo2 12 MB (SLI...)
    Creative Labs Sound Blaster Live!
    Klipsch ProMedia v.2-400
    Quantum Viking 4.5 GB UW SCSI (weak...)
    Creative Labs PC-DVD Encore 2X
    Iomega 1GB Jazz

    All running on Win2000...

    Comment


    • #3
      Tried the unoverclocked cards with unoverclocked CPU, at default AGP speed (66MHz), with AGP forced to 1x (the default was 2x and exhibited the behavior), all drivers versions since 5.25, with the SBLive! removed. What's more, the same setup worked flawlessly with my old G200 card and with a TNT2 Pro
      Asus A7V, Duron 600@900, 192MB PC133@100, G200, Guillemot MUSE, etc.

      Comment


      • #4
        My question is: From whom have you gotten these 3 cards??

        All from the same place? Or not?

        I understand that having had problems with 3 identical cards you might get the idea that there's some kind of defect in the part in general and of course sometimes that does happen....

        ...but if I had to say whether the likely source of your problems was:[list=1][*] Because a manufacturer (Matrox) released large numbers of a defective product into the distribution channel, despite the fact that their livelihood depends on not doing so, for several reasons;[*] Because a user (you) has a configuration issue within their system which obviously remains unresolved, since replacement parts (at least one of which should have been good simply on the basis of chance) have not changed the symptoms...[/list=a]

        ...Well, I think I'd check out that config error thing. I see that you have "searched on flicker", and have mentioned this issue before, but I've not seen that you requested a dedicated focus of our attention on this.

        Perhaps you should.

        Just a concept.....

        ----------------------------
        Holly

        Comment


        • #5
          (again...)
          Have you tried the cards on other machines?

          Jon
          My baby...

          QDI Brilliant IV - Bios 2.0 Beta (Win2000 updates - email me if you want it!)
          2 Pentium III 500 MHz
          256 MB PC-100 SDRAM
          Matrox Millenium G200 8 MB SGRAM - Bios 2.6-20
          2 Creative Labs 3D Blaster Voodoo2 12 MB (SLI...)
          Creative Labs Sound Blaster Live!
          Klipsch ProMedia v.2-400
          Quantum Viking 4.5 GB UW SCSI (weak...)
          Creative Labs PC-DVD Encore 2X
          Iomega 1GB Jazz

          All running on Win2000...

          Comment


          • #6
            Sounds like a refresh problem. Have tried adjusting this. Try looking up your monitor on the web and downloading a new driver. You can also create a specilist monitor profile within the powerdesk.
            You try another card however I can't see three cards being faulty unless your dealer is giving the same card back to you.
            You haven't installed anything that creates magnetic field nearby your monitor.
            Chief Lemon Buyer no more Linux sucks but not as much
            Weather nut and sad git.

            My Weather Page

            Comment


            • #7
              There have been numerous threads on this. Last autumn I tried two different 16MB G400's. Both had this problem. Bought a 32MB Dualhead and have never seen it ever since. Try running something 3D-accelerated in a window(like WinTune98). Ouch.
              Jan

              Comment


              • #8
                I have the same problem with a 16mb single head oem card I purchased back in October. Stubbornly refusing to believe there was a problem with a 2-d portion of a Matrox card, I tried multiple things before finally receiveing an RMA for replacement. Things I tried; Reformat and fresh install of Win98, new power supply, different monitors at multiple refresh rates, different driver versions, and even tried the card in my friend's system. Nothing would make the flicker disappear. And JMS is right, some applications and programs are much worse than others. I'm currently running a Banshee(yuck) while I wait for my replacement. I guess I shouldn't say yuck, because my flicker problem is nonexistant with the Banshee, but I want my G400 back. I sure hope the problem is resolved with the new card or I think I'm going to cry. The RMA process slow, and the prospects of returning another card and the coresponding wait are grim. - Autopilot

                Comment


                • #9
                  At least you've got a Banshee. I'm looking at a couple weeks of Permedia2 action while my 16mbG400 is gone
                  Has anyone tried requesting a 32mb replacement part (paying the difference of course)? I don't look forward to going through this more than once, and it does seem to be a problem with just the 16mb parts.
                  Games Box
                  --------------
                  Windows 2000Pro, ASUS A7Pro, Duron 750@950, 192MB Micron PC133, OEM Radeon DDR, 15gb Quantum Fireball+ LM, Fujitsu 5.25gb, Pioneer 32x slot load CDROM, SB Live! Value, LinkSys LNE100, Altec Lansing ACS45.2, Samsung Syncmaster 955DF, Sycom 300va UPS

                  Video Box
                  ------
                  Windows 2000Pro, PIII700 on ASUS CUBX, 256mb Micron PC133, Vanilla G400/32 (PD5.14), Hauppage WinTV-DBX, LinkSys LNE100, 8.4gb Maxtor HD, 40gb 7200 Western Digital, Diamond Fireport 40 SCSI, Pioneer 32x SCSI Slot load CDROM, Pioneer 10x Slot load DVD, Yamaha 4416s burner, MX300, Panasonic Panasync S70

                  Feline Tech Support
                  -------------
                  Jinx the Grey Thundercat, Mischa (Shilsner?)(still MIA)

                  ...currently working on the world's first C64 based parallel computing project

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    OK, OK, I believe you (all)!!!

                    Just thinking out loud... you are all talking about the 16MB SH part, right?

                    I kinda wonder if, since they were early parts and OEM parts, if for once there was a reason that they should have gone to OEMs only, because it almost sounds like that might be Windows looking for the other head (which of course is not there).

                    Does anyone still have the part in?? Just wondering what the 'multiple monitors' CP box looks like with such a card installed.

                    If this has any substance as a possibility, maybe OEMs had to themselves do something to have the SH perceived as a true single-head part... but then again, I've been told not to speculate before now )

                    -------------------------------------
                    Holly

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Holly
                      I've still got mine in...I don't have any 'Multiple Monitors' controls available in my display properties. Just looks like any other single vid card setup would.
                      I don't think there are any 'OEM specific' drivers needed. The ones that shipped with the CD are the same as what ships with the retail box.
                      Games Box
                      --------------
                      Windows 2000Pro, ASUS A7Pro, Duron 750@950, 192MB Micron PC133, OEM Radeon DDR, 15gb Quantum Fireball+ LM, Fujitsu 5.25gb, Pioneer 32x slot load CDROM, SB Live! Value, LinkSys LNE100, Altec Lansing ACS45.2, Samsung Syncmaster 955DF, Sycom 300va UPS

                      Video Box
                      ------
                      Windows 2000Pro, PIII700 on ASUS CUBX, 256mb Micron PC133, Vanilla G400/32 (PD5.14), Hauppage WinTV-DBX, LinkSys LNE100, 8.4gb Maxtor HD, 40gb 7200 Western Digital, Diamond Fireport 40 SCSI, Pioneer 32x SCSI Slot load CDROM, Pioneer 10x Slot load DVD, Yamaha 4416s burner, MX300, Panasonic Panasync S70

                      Feline Tech Support
                      -------------
                      Jinx the Grey Thundercat, Mischa (Shilsner?)(still MIA)

                      ...currently working on the world's first C64 based parallel computing project

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Oh, well, it was just an idea that came to my fevered brain...

                        ------------------
                        Holly

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Judging from the numerous posts in previous threads this seems to be a fairly common problem. And yes, I got all replacements from the same dealer and they were are s/n JBJxxxxx.

                          However, everything suggests it's not just a bad batch but a more serious problem. I'll get a 32MB replacement as soon as they bring them in and as soon as I'll get the money for it (approx $70 more for a 32DH). But I don't need DH (they don't import 32SH) and I don't need 32MB. For me the card I got is ideal.

                          I wish Matrox would say something. I have mailed them a while a go with a link to the most interesting and illuminating thread here. Maybe that's why they are not answering back...
                          Asus A7V, Duron 600@900, 192MB PC133@100, G200, Guillemot MUSE, etc.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Well soon after I made my first post in this thread, the UPS man showed up with my replacement card from Matrox. Quick turnaround guys, cheers to Matrox TS and RMA.
                            I just got it installed and the problem is gone. Praise the video card gods! And Holly, I think you were on to something with your speculation concerning the problem. Well, I just wanted to report that there is another Matrox satisfied customer. Thanks to all. So hang in there guys, there is hope

                            [This message has been edited by Autopilot (edited 24 February 2000).]

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              I have the same problem. It is a major pain. At least now I know it is not my monitor dying. Maybe it's a defective RAMDAC shipment.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X